I bought this book in December when I heard so much buzz about it that I had to have it.
And then it sat on my bedside table untouched until last week.
It wasn’t that I didn’t want to read it, but I have noticed that Nick Hornby was onto something with his Polysyllabic Spree columns – I have a tendency to collect more than I can reasonably read at any given time.
That aside, the timing was perfect for this book. My son participated in the Young Writers Academy last week and worked with his fellow students of writing to create fractured fairy tales. So I felt like I had read more Grimm in the week leading up than I had ever read before at one time. We scrambled up a two volume set of fairy tales (many of them Grimm’s) and set to work.
I was surprised at how bloody some of them were.
You don’t notice this when you read them the first time for yourself. You notice it when you are reading them to a five-year-old.
Cut off fingers.Cut off toes. Decapitated children. Murder after murder.
Yep. This is the stuff bedtime stories are made of.
EXCEPT…he loved them and asked for more.
Apparently Mr. Gidwitz found the same experience when his principal came to read one of Grimm’s tales to his second grade class. He was far more bent out of shape about the whole thing than the students were.
This led him to read a few more. And a few more. And realize, after all this research, that they are really just parts of the same story. Just Grimm mixes up the names in some.
But Mr. Gidwitz sets us straight. They are clearly all about Hansel and Gretel. And to make sure we understand it, he walks us through their lives from the time their father is warned by Faithful Johannes NOT to go into one particular room, NOT to go meet this beautiful woman in the picture in this room. But, of course, he does and Faithful Johannes does what he can to allow them to be together – a decision that allows our Hansel and Gretel to be born but also puts this frightening tale into motion.
And to make sure that WE don’t have nightmares, the narrator barges in at key moments to warn us to get small children out of the room or to avoid this part altogether: just too scary.
Glad I had it around when I was ready.
Related Reading:
* Grimm’s Fairy Tales
* Grimm’s Grimmest by Maria Tatar
* Sisters Grimm series by Michael Buckley and Peter Ferguson
* Nursery Crimes series by Jasper Fforde (yes, I know nursery rhymes & fairy tales are NOT the same, but trust me on this)
* Gregory Maguire’s retellings like Confessions of an Ugly Stepsister
As I remember more, I’ll add them.